Eastgate Mall opened in Glen Este in 1980 with nearly 100 stores under one roof. As of May 2026, it held 34. As WCPO reported, Furniture Connection owner Jack Cary said last fall that his lease at the mall's center court was ending that spring and wouldn't be renewed. Time Warp Cards & Comics owner Ron Taylor signed a letter of intent on a new address after what he described as years of frustration with the mall's Georgia-based ownership. L.A. Nails, a tenant there for more than a decade, confirmed plans to relocate too, citing declining foot traffic in the wing anchored by JCPenney.
None of that is in dispute. What's less settled is what it means for the houses two streets away in Cherry Grove.
The assumption is easy to reach on its own. A mall that has lost two-thirds of its stores, is tangled in an ownership lawsuit, and is legally barred from major redevelopment until March 4, 2030 should be dragging nearby home values down with it. Over the past year, the number that actually moved in Cherry Grove went the other direction.
What Sold, And For How Much Per Foot
Closed-sale data through August 2026 tells two different stories depending on which number you read.
| Metric (trailing 3 months through August 2026) | Cherry Grove | Anderson Township |
|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $350,000, down 0.66% year over year | $395,000, down 7.1% year over year |
| Price per square foot | $183, up 7.0% year over year | $189, down 1.0% year over year |
| Median days on market | 38, versus 37 a year earlier | 38, versus 41 a year earlier |
| Homes sold in August | 17, versus 19 a year earlier | 195, versus 189 a year earlier |
Read the median column alone and Cherry Grove looks flat and Anderson Township looks like it's cooling by more than seven points. Read the price per square foot column and the story flips. Cherry Grove buyers are paying more for the same square footage than they were a year ago. Anderson Township buyers are paying almost exactly what they were.
What Price Per Square Foot Is Doing That The Median Can't
A median is a single sorted number. It tells you what the middle house sold for, and nothing about whether that house looks like the one that sold in the middle last year. Price per square foot is a blunter instrument in some ways, but it strips out one variable the median can't touch: size.
Cherry Grove's 17 closed sales in August is a thin sample, about a tenth the size of Anderson Township's 195. A thin market moves in bigger steps on any single metric, which is worth remembering before treating one month's 7% swing in price per square foot as a permanent trend. But the direction lines up with what happens when updated, move-in-ready homes make up a larger share of what's trading in a smaller market. Buyers competing for those homes are pricing the finish work and the condition, not the mall's legal calendar four miles away.
Anderson Township's larger sample tells a mix-shift story instead of a value story. Current inventory in the township includes multi-acre estates near the river, several over 10,000 square feet, sitting alongside typical three and four bedroom homes on quarter-acre lots. When the kind of home that closes in a given quarter shifts, even slightly, toward fewer of those large estate sales and more of the standard housing stock, the median drops even though no individual comparable house lost value. A price per square foot that barely moved while the median fell 7.1% is close to a textbook signal of exactly that.
The 2030 Deadline That's Freezing Everything Else
The mall's ownership dispute is a matter of public court record. RCC Eastgate Mall LLC, which owns the parcel under the mall's former Big Lots space, sued Hull Property Group this year. The complaint alleges that common areas, the roof, and the parking lot were left to deteriorate, with estimated maintenance costs of more than $4 million. Hull Property Group acquired the mall in 2023, and the claims are allegations that the courts have yet to resolve.
The reason none of that translates into fast change is structural. The mall's five main owners, including Kroger and Hull, hold mutual veto power over each other's redevelopment plans under reciprocal easement agreements that don't expire until March 4, 2030. As Local 12 reported, Cary put it bluntly: that's when "the Wild Wild West comes." Until then, any owner can block another's plan, and the arrangement gives each of them reason to prefer the status quo over a costly fight for change.
Union Township produced a 100-acre master plan for the site back in 2024, with input from residents who wanted the mall's middle section reimagined into mixed-use space. That plan still exists. It has no binding timeline, and the easement agreements mean it can't move faster than 2030 regardless of how much community appetite there is for it.
Why The Correlation Isn't Showing Up
The instinct to link a struggling commercial anchor to falling home values isn't wrong as a general rule. It just runs on a different clock than most residential transactions. A house closes in 30 to 45 days once an offer is accepted. A five-party easement agreement resolves on whatever date it says it resolves, which in this case is a specific day in 2030, not a gradual drift.
Buyers writing offers on Cherry Grove homes this year are pricing the roof, the kitchen, and the lot in front of them. They are not discounting for a legal deadline in 2030, and the per-square-foot number reflects that. If Eastgate's vacancy and litigation were pulling residential values down in any direct, immediate way, it would be the more sensitive of the two metrics, price per square foot, that would show it first, given how thin the Cherry Grove sample already is. Instead it moved up.
That doesn't mean the mall's fate is irrelevant to the neighborhood forever. It means the two stories are currently running on separate timelines, and treating them as a single, currently-linked trend overstates what the data supports right now.
What To Actually Ask When Comparing Cherry Grove To Its Neighbors
A few questions get past the headline number faster than debating the median in isolation.
- What is the price per square foot trend doing, not just the median, and over how many months
- How many homes actually closed in the window being quoted. Seventeen sales carries a different confidence level than 195
- What size and condition were the homes that sold. A shift toward smaller or larger properties can move a median without moving value
- Is the commercial story next door tied to a specific mechanism, like a school levy or a business closing that affects local employment, or is it a separate legal timeline that doesn't touch residential resale on the same schedule
FAQ
Does a struggling shopping mall always pull down nearby home values? Not on any fixed timeline, based on what this data shows. Cherry Grove's price per square foot moved up over the past year even as Eastgate Mall's vacancies grew and its ownership dispute became public record. The two markets can move independently, at least over a year or two.
When will the Eastgate Mall situation actually change? The reciprocal easement agreements among the mall's main owners, including Kroger and Hull Property Group, don't expire until March 4, 2030. Major redevelopment decisions are effectively on hold until then, regardless of how the current repair lawsuit is resolved.
Is 17 home sales in a month enough to trust the numbers for Cherry Grove? It's enough to show direction, not enough to treat one month as a verdict. That's the case for tracking price per square foot over several quarters alongside the median rather than reading either number by itself.
If you're weighing Cherry Grove against Anderson Township, Union Township, or another east-side community, the median on a listing page won't tell you which one actually fits your budget the way price per square foot and the real closed comps will. Lori Williams can walk through those comps property by property before you write an offer.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.